2009 mini cooper reliability reddit

2009 mini cooper reliability reddit. CoPilot reports that several 2010 to 2013 Countryman problems are safety hazards, such as fires and engine failures. Questions about 2007 Mini Cooper S reliability. Power deemed the Mini Cooper as its most dependable compact car and ranked the Mini brand fourth overall for dependability. As the title states, I’m looking to purchasing a used Mini Cooper. Dealer maintained, all scheduled service, responsible adult driven. This is especially true of the S and JCW models. The We had $10k in repairs from 0-100k miles in a '14 R60 Countryman, with N18 motor. The final thing was a blown head gasket. The F-chassis, which launched with the 2014 Hardtop 2dr, has been awesome in terms of long term reliability. Both new MINIs and Classic Minis are… Hi, I’ve been chasing a 2016 Mini Cooper S Hardtop with the JCW package which currently have around 140,000 miles with clean title. Specifically 2007-2011. Stay far away from these. Most common problems with those years are probably the power steering pump going out and various leaks in the engine that’s all I can think about. The main problems of the 2009 Mini Cooper are the following: Loud noises and the engine stops when started cold. One of them was 1700 for the part". Sadly, my 17-year-old Lexus ES 350 requires another $2000+ repair (after another $2000 repair a few months ago), so I've decided she's earned her retirement and it's time to get something else. The average annual repair cost is $609 which means it has average ownership costs. The current Clubman shares a platform and drivetrain with the F60 Mini Countryman, and BMW X1 and X2, with a variant of BMW xDrive intelligent AWD system being offered as an option called ALL4. Also the bodykit on the Cooper S makes it look all the more subtle, yet aggressive (compared to the JCW). The 2014 is probably more reliable than a 2011. Surprisingly quick around town and will hold 70 on the motorway all day long. Mini Cooper 2009. Non s is even more reliable as you don't have to worry about the supercharger. 6 times, which is higher than the general average of 0. If it has a speedometer in the middle of the dash like this one has avoid. No problems, only regular maintenance. It’s not a Camry or a Civic, you gotta regularly Sep 16, 2023 · Key Points: The best year for Mini Cooper reliability depends on the specific generation and model. View Pricing Information. Negative points (maybe that’s a bit strong, more like not-so-good points) - it’s noisy, especially when cold. KidEgo74. if it was taken care of don’t sweat the mileage too much. Only normal oil changes and break pads had to be done. Take it to a mechanic to get a good thorough look. (It took me one hour to do myself) The part cost me 200 dollars. Our reliability score is based on the J. The 2004 one hasn’t had clutch changed but is a one owner car, and convertible. You’d know right away as it causes a rough idle. Jul 21, 2020 · In 2019, J. May 16, 2021 · CoPilot advises avoiding 2012, 2013, and 2014 coupes and 2012 and 2013 roadsters. In addition, 13% of Mini Cooper repairs are considered severe, slightly higher than the overall average of 12%. 114 votes, 30 comments. $1200 at local shop. Anonymous, CA (2010 Mini Cooper S 1. I currently drive a 2007 MKV GTI 3 dr manual and am considering trading for a 2010 Mini Cooper S JCW. Best check the reliability reports. Cooper is a 1. 2. I test drove the mini and really enjoyed the go kart feel and found the engine quite torquey in the lower power bands making it very exciting to drive. That leads to timing chain issues, which in turn can lead to engine failure if allowed to go unchecked. Repairs are less severe and less frequent than the average car, so the Jetta is one of the more reliable vehicles on the road. The worst Mini Cooper Countryman years include 2011, 2012, and 2013. com. The VW is a more powerful and better handling and driving car. More. Business, Economics, and Finance. If you’re not prepared for that trade off it may not be for Apr 2, 2021 · The ‘main’ lineup consists of the ‘F55’ 3-door and ‘F56’ 5-door Cooper and Cooper S, and the ‘F57’ Convertible. We expect the 2024 Cooper will be more reliable than the average new car. Just a beautiful color on the car. Averages 50 mpg overall so cheap to run. Nearly 60 years after its debut, the Mini Cooper lives on as an endearing icon. I bought a 2013 Mini Cooper Hardtop back in 2012. Repair centers will always wastegate fix: 8k at dealer, 3k at local shop. I would mainly use it as my daily commuter vehicle to and from work (30 miles/day). 6-liter four-cylinder that produces 118 horsepower and 114 pound-feet of torque. 00 to replace the gasket. However, it does feel quite small after the GTI (I am also 6"2). I’ve been doing quite a bit of research, but it’s tough to find straight-up answers on Google about the 2006 Mini Cooper S. From the photos, car looks great on both interior/exterior and probably mileage is not excessive (20,000mi/year). Modding. Power and Associates Vehicle Dependability Study (VDS) rating or, if unavailable, the J. They are very aware the group around them drive their cars harder than normal. not to mention I love the design of a Mini Cooper, and I think it’s the more unique and charming vehicle out there. 2009 Mini Cooper with 79000 miles for 3900 2012 fiat 500 sport with 13000 miles for… It’s a warranty item or out of warranty, it’s like a $170 part. Your budget gives you a couple of options. Otherwise, they are probably expensive to insure for young drivers. Right, that’s the consensus I’ve been hearing. Contrary to its reputation, the latest Mini Coopers are reliable cars, MotoringFile reports. Oct 18, 2023 · The most important MINI Cooper Clubman years to avoid include: 2008 MINI Cooper Clubman. I've owned several high mileage cars in the past, a few over 200k. I currently drive a Hyundai Sonata, and I’m about to move to a big city so I wanted something smaller and easier to navigate, park, etc. Many years ago (2009) horrible reliability with my Mini experience but it was a great drive, so much that I just go this (2019). 2020 Mini Cooper S | Mini. Any car as it ages and gets higher mileage will likely need more care once in awhile, but B-motors tend to last a pretty long time. While range is a concern, the EPA numbers are accurate, which helps a lot. Would definitely suggest getting a thorough pre-purchase inspection. "Needed new fuel pumps for the existing two that a mini has. $115 in parts. ”. Road Test First time car buyer, here are the two options I’m considering. The newer 2-series Gran Coupe, which other than being obscenely ugly, is a MINI underneath completely, albeit with the newer 300hp John Cooper Works motor. Non-S second gens I didn’t hear about any reoccurring issues really. So far it has had to have the transmission replaced, the clutch replaced Really like the idea of a micro hot-ish hatch. Which is why the Mini can handle power upgrades so well. Aug 9, 2022 · The 2009 Cooper had a total of 11 complaints at CarComplaints. A base model non-S won’t be as bad as you don’t have turbo-related failures, but they’re still not great. It still cost me thousands of dollars for the new engine. Reply reply. The For routine stuff, lets’s say you need to do 3 oil changes a year and a set of brakes. Worst used car: Mini Cooper S. 5. Somehow coolant mixed with engine oil. The Cooper S hatchback features a turbocharged version of the same engine that Jan 4, 2016 · Where This Vehicle Ranks. 6, the N14. Both are about the same price. CoPilot recognizes the reported steering and powertrain issues These are fun cars, some of the funniest to drive, but require deep pockets And deep knowledge. If it's a fun car to drive, I want it. For first-gen Mini Coopers, the 2005 and 2006 models are considered the most desirable and reliable, with 2006 being the most reliable option. I have plenty of space and both of my dogs fit in the backyard. NA. 2009 MINI Cooper Clubman. $5,919 - $8,188 AVG PRICE PAID. release. For coupes you want 2005-2006 for convertibles from 2005-2008 (all first Gen verts are solid). Hey guys, need some advise here. I’m looking into getting a Mini and join all the fun. Power hasn’t reviewed the 2006 Mini Cooper, but CoPilot lists it and 2016 as the two most reliable Mini Cooper model years. The 228 has the N20 turbo, which makes about 240hp to the crank, and the 230i has the B48, but bore out to almost 250hp. When it comes to choosing a used car, you can put the odds on your side by choosing a model that performed well when new and has a great reliability track record. Jan 31, 2023 · In line with the recall, 191 complaints related to airbag issues, 108 involved steering issues, and power train problems came in third with 45 reports. The N12 and N14 engines are notoriously unreliable and have a lot of common, expensive problems. Of course, reliability hiccups can happen with any used car, but the Mini Cooper S has the worst history among all cars we have tracked over the past Nov 9, 2023 · The FIXD Reliability Score ranges from 1 (poor) to 10 (perfect), with 5 being average. 2024 Mini Cooper. Yet, a review of FIXD Reliability Scores for the Mini Cooper revealed a surprise: very few model years had low scores. It's the first European car I've ever bought and every car I'd owned before this was a Toyota/Honda/Nissan (from more reliable years) and I came from the mentality of "reliable Japanese cars" r/MechanicAdvice. Oil found in the coolant reservoir. The thing about modding an R53 is its proven track record. went out and bought it to replace her old Chrysler 300 daily driver. 56K subscribers in the MINI community. 0 turbo 4, the B46, making 189hp. The Cooper S has a more subtle look, which I feel is kind of nice! I’m thinking of going Rooftop Grey for the Cooper S. These cars consume oil. While the non-turbo Cooper models are definitely better than the S models, that era isn’t exactly known for reliability so would be really getting that thing checked out. The mini will be about $500 for tires. I don't know much about Minis, so I was wondering if any of you I own a 2009 mini cooper. If your heart is set on a MINI, get a gen 3 F series. 62K subscribers in the MINI community. 2009 Toyota Yaris. The GTI is faster and can easily push more power with an APR tune, but it didn't feel as fun as the F55/F56. While it's usable as an only car, it's much more convenient as a 2nd car. When I researched more though, most websites say that anything 2014 or 2015 later, the F56, is a solid car. I had to sell my 2013 Mini Cooper S for scrap last week (2085 dollars)…. I'm looking at a bare bones base 2016 Mini coop or a ford fiesta st. Although this is not the car to buy if you’re expecting Toyota reliability, it’s super fun to drive which makes up for any issues that arise. Gotcha. I would look for a 2012-13 if you want an R56 bodystyle. Obviously they have to make some adjustments to timing and things like, the block, head, cams, and crank shaft need to be different. So far, so good. Countryman feels big enough for me after driving a small SUV prior. But things like pistons, crank arms, coil packs and the like are shared across all of the engines. MINI should not be your first car unless you have tons of money burning a hole in your pocket to pay for repairs. With a stick, they are pretty good as far as reliability even now. I wanted a mini so bad but I have a phobia of small cars after doing a 360 in a small 2 door on a major highway. The service intervals can be so far between that we see dry dipsticks quite frequently. While looking at Mini Cooper years to buy and reliability, I have seen a few sites list the 2015 year as one to avoid. But in my time at a MINI dealer, that really was the only thing I’d see that generation In the second gen 07-10 S models have tons of issues (N14 engine) and should be avoided. New hot hatches like the GTI and ST siblings are better, as are other two doors like the Toyobarus and EB Mustang. At a dealership, you’re looking at prob $1,200-1,300 total. MINIs are fucking fun to drive, but don't have the power of the GTI. I mean nothing is guaranteed of course, but I’d feel better telling you to get a high mileage F56 than a high mileage R56. Called MINI and complained as I was faithful with having it serviced at the dealer. So just be prepared/budget accordingly to fix and maintain the car. The old one is not bad in my opinion, I liked it, but it has less storage space than the Clubman (47. ago. The latest Mini Coopers are generally reliable and recommended by Consumer Reports. The new MINI's have been around for 11 years and the FR-S for over 1 year, the MINI is refined now. Also the Bayswater edition is beautiful I really want to get one. My coworker owns a 2010 mini cooper s. It’s not a ideal “only car” or “starter car. I know it costs more, but when you factor in the repairs the R needs it is not that much more. 6-L 4 Cyl turbo) Sensors (includes O2 or oxygen The Volkswagen Jetta Reliability Rating is 4. Power’s rankings indicate that the Mini Cooper’s quality has significantly improved. And, as before, there are JCW trims and the Mini Cooper JCW GP. Both new MINIs and Classic Minis are… Modern BMW's (and Mini's) as of about 2016, depending on model, are much more reliable than BMW's in the past. Car prices continue to climb — a maxed out CRV is now just shy of $38K (!!!) and nowhere near as fun, or as luxurious, as one of these. $6,277 - $6,815 AVG PRICE PAID. -price -reliability -cost of repair. That is NOT to say they dont require typical BMW maintenance though, which if you're not a DIYer, will add up quickly. After spending about $8000 in the last year on various repairs including a new turbo unit, thermostat, coolant hoses, solenoid, and other things. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. Not sure if this is the right place to ask. $180 in parts/fluid done myself. 2009 Mini Cooper Clubman. I have a 2011 Countryman, so the first year they made the R60. For example, the 2010 MINI Cooper Clubman only had about 80 complaints, while the 2011 MINI Cooper Clubman cut that If it’s a base model with the CVT automatic, no they are not, specifically the transmission is not. Mini released its current generation of cars as early as 2014, so it’s possible to buy a Mini with low miles at a low price $15-$25k. Gen3: Everything is turbocharged. This prediction is based on data from 2021, 2022, and 2023 models, plus the Mini brand scores. The 2020 Mini also earned a top They are not to be honest. Meant I was changing the oil around 7500 miles, plus the break in oil change. As an r53 owner who is also in the market for another car, I wouldn't recommend the F56. r/JeepRenegade. Covers under my extended maintenance. Currently I’m looking at a 2004 Cooper with 150k miles, and a 2010 Cooper S with 100k miles. The average Mini unscheduled repair visits are approximately 0. Power ranked the Mini as 28th out of 32 for reliability. The Subaru is a good car, though the EJ motors are not without their problems Sep 21, 2023 · The 2009 Mini Cooper has over 300 NHTSA complaints and three recalls, with one of its prominent reliability issues being engine stops or loud noises when starting cold. 1. D. The Fiesta is a more usable size, but I love go-cart the feeling if driving the mini in the city. Nothing particularly special about the color, but also nothing over the top. She usually comes to me and/or my uncle for mechanical advice, but she never asked me about this one. I personally would love to own a mini in the future. Side note, I went to an actual MINI dealer and the salesman did say the R53 motor was in his opinion the best and most reliable they've made. The issue with minis is people buy them as alternatives to cars like Prius’s, Camry’s, Civic’s, Accord’s, etc. 101,000 km. And although $50K seems like a lot, this is a fully optioned Countryman. No problems other than that. 6-L 4 Cyl turbo) "It was leaking oil from the vale cover gasket and they wanted $2800. The electric is based on the BMW i3, which was on the market for over 10 years with very few problems. $4,213 - $7,363 AVG PRICE PAID. This prediction is based on data from 2021, 2022, and 2023 models, plus the Mini brand scores With MINI’s, the reliability woes you read about are from the 2nd generation. • 6 yr. 2013 is said to be a reliable year. They are just about the same price, 0-60 time, and handling specs, but I like the mpg projections for the Mini better than the Fiesta. Please remember Mini sells every model with two engines, a 3-cylinder and a 4-cylinder. 2009 Honda Fit. 2011-2013 they fixed the issues mostly (N18 engine) and are considered much more reliable. The base Mini Cooper comes with a 1. There is a 2007 Mini Cooper S 6-speed that I am considering buying because I could get a killer deal on it. Compare. Its somewhat reliable. RWD. Plus points - pulls strong from low revs, plenty torque and power. If reliability and operating costs are your concern, the current generation of Mini models are an excellent choice. 106 votes, 13 comments. I wouldn’t let your friend dissuade you, especially if you instantly loved the car. The 2011 and 2012 Mini Cooper models have many trouble spots, including the engine, fuel system, electric system, and more. Usually, I’ll set 3 as the bare minimum score for a vehicle to be considered for the best years list. 2009 Scion xD. That said you have to keep up with the maint and take care of your car. com and 151 problems at CarProblemZoo. Overall Reliability. Shocks/struts (replaced at 140k): $2500 at dealer. MINIs are notorious for being expensive to repair, and since the 3rd Gen is “newer” and has more “BMW parts” it can definitely be a challenge to find a good repair center. Also, avoid the automatic at all costs. We're just two people in the sea of many mini owners. If you decide on a MINI, get a 05'-06' R53, 2011-2013 R56, or 2014+ F55/F56. 2018 Mini Cooper S Hatchback 2D 110k miles Clean Title 2 Owners asking $11,500 Seems like a pretty good deal, but it has enough miles on it that I'm worried it's quickly going to become a money pit, and I haven't found much documentation on long-term reliability for this new of a Mini. $25,800 - $44,900. Ideally I’ll buy a used model with less than 70k miles on it, and use it only as well a car, so commenting to and from work (about 3-4hrs However. MINIs overall are extremely reliable, and backed by a great warranty, and with 04 and 05s all major complaints have been resolved. Ixnay on Minis. Consumer Reports lists the 2015 model year for the Mini Cooper as one to “Never Buy”. Originally produced in 1959 by the British Motor Corporation, Mini later became a part of BMW, which would eventually expand its sales overseas. How fucked I'm I? I spent over $100 on an oil change back in August, today I was told my engine was having issues with the timing at the same shop I got the oil change. Due to the issues with the N12/14 powerplants, in 2011, revised versions, the N16 (Cooper) and N18 (Cooper S) were launched. Four years prior, J. I've driven many vehicles with way more power, but the handling/razor sharp turn-in, paired with its buttery smooth shifting, hilarious exhaust, torquey turbo, quirky styling and all that there is to love about them, I find myself coming back to the F56 in what's been years of finding the right car The horror stories you’ve been hearing are for years 2013 and older, the general consensus is that 2014+ is significantly more reliable. But at it’s core they’re BMWs, a typical BMW owner will maintain their BMW as they pay BMW money, a typical mini owner neglects the same treatment a BMW owner would give. brownumbrellaperson. So an ‘09 Cooper S would be a turbocharged 1. I had to go to three different collision centers before I found one that I felt was capable of repairing it properly and used OEM parts. Btw comparison the mini has about 20hp less and they weight roughly the same, performance-wise the only difference is FWD vs. A dealer will try to charge you $1,000+ but it isn’t that expensive, have an independent shop do that if you even encounter it at all. Timing chains, solenoid valves, and pumps go out more often than other cars it seems. If it’s was maintained properly go for it. The Jeep Renegade (BU) is a subcompact crossover SUV from the Jeep division of Fiat Chrysler Automobiles. I’ve been wanting a more exciting vehicle with a We got 30 mpg overall in from the 189-hp, turbo four-cylinder Cooper S we tested with the six-speed manual. For owners and fans of the mighty Mini Cooper. With surprisingly nice driving dynamics and range that matches the estimates, I think the Electric MINI is a lot of car for the price if you have a place to charge it. J. If anything else comes up, really just depends. And be really super preventative with maintenance. 5 turbo 3, the B38 BMW engine, making 134hp, and Cooper S is a 2. The I figure this question is asked a lot, but I’m looking to buy my first car and thought the MINI Cooper looked nice. As mentioned, both cars can hit that 210-220WHP for around the same price. Oil changes are once a year or every 10k, whichever comes first. Anonymous, GA (2013 Mini Cooper S 1. The car itself is quite reliable otherwise though. 4 visits. I never saw them in for major services at all, they’re pretty much tanks. They may have shit build quality and shit reliability but people still love em. If there is a particular model of MINI that tends to last (like the R53) then I could possibly save up and buy a higher mileage one with Honestly, this is like the same story as Alfa Romeo. 0, which ranks it 21st out of 36 for compact cars. The mechanic told me it was due to not having enough oil? Overall Reliability. The No warning light no symptoms nothing. The new Mazda3 is a sweet car. Jul 13, 2021 · Jul 13, 2021. I want a MINI Cooper so bad but concerned about safety/reliability also looking at Subaru Crosstrek and Volkswagen GTI help! Hey everyone. Feb 26, 2024 · Another area where the Mini Cooper’s reliability ratings have taken a hit is with repair frequency. When it comes to car buying my biggest things are. Someone wanted 400-500 dollars to do a one hour job for example. ) your maintenance cost will be reasonable. Jan 4, 2016 · 2009 MINI Cooper Reliability Ratings. They are not BMW engines, but rather French Peugeot motors co-designed with BMW. . We actually just ranked third in predicted reliability in Consumer Reports about a month ago. Additionally, the Cooper has a crossover sibling, the Countryman. At an independent shop, prob $600-700 for the same. If you can’t afford a $3,000 repair bill, buy something more reliable and, yes, more boring. Perhaps one of the new Cooper S or a JCW Cooper. Additional $14k from 100-160k. 70lb lab mix and 50lb blue heeler. 00 and replaced Ah, I have a 2010 N14 jcw, they are a big no no and unless your going to do your work yourself. Fuel pump. There are more 250-300WHP R53s out there than 2nd gens. I give MINI credit for paying for 75% of the cost of the engine. As such, you're going to be replacing worn About 9 months ago I purchased a 2009 Mini Cooper S automatic from a Mini dealership. This may be too off topic, but MINI has just strayed too far from what made them great in '02. I purchased the gasket for $24. Clutch worn out prematurely. If it’s a Cooper S with the 6spd automatic, they aren’t horrible but they have failures with the transmission as well. That one may have been complimentary from my dealer though. Got it at 46K now I'm close to 59K. It’s so much more fun than basically any other little SUV. upvotes ·. Since a lot of the parts are smaller (smaller tires, smaller brakes, etc. A 2013 S Model with 70k miles to be specific. S. 9 cubic ft with the seats folded). Gas mileage on an S model will be in the mid-20's, higher for the non-S models. You're still looking at very expensive repairs, though - the Ford SVT shares the 1st gen Cooper clutch and it's upwards of $800, IIRC, vs a regular old $100-$200 Focus clutch But at the very least it's better than the Peugeot atrocity in your 09 example. After that, the R53 starts costing more as mechanical parts need to be swapped out, but 250WHP is easy enough. Obsessed with my Countryman. Had a rattle when it was very cold and it was a quick fix. Fall of 2018 the original fan capacitor went out, which lead to a series of events leading up to suspected head warping. Hey redditors, I have a co worker who is thinking about purchasing a 2015 mini S for 13,000 at 35,000 miles from a friend of his Hey guys, I'm considering purchasing a F56 Cooper S 6 speed this summer as my first real car. Brakes: $1200 at dealer. On the fence about buying 2006 Mini S. After this point, complaints drop beneath 100 for each vehicle year model on average, getting better all the time. Crypto Reply. 2005-06 R53s are also reliable, and you can't beat the supercharger whine! R53 is solid, there old so you're gonna have to replace wear items, and old rubber stuff of the last owner hasn't, Ex-MINI sales and current owner here. Power Predicted Reliability rating. You see, BMW uses rubber bushings as an active part of its suspension. That was my only repair in the last year. It has just under 80k miles. As an example, I had to put new tires on my BMW X5 and it was $1200. The F54 Clubman (2016-present) is a very reliable car. The Renegade is the first Jeep product to be produced exclusively outside of North America and will sell in South Take it from somebody who has worked for this brand, for the last near 10 model years, ICE MINI have been very reliable vehicles. Spark plugs: $180 at dealer. Just a couple weeks ago we had to replace the coils, plugs, and valve cover. They are all 500cc per cylinder and share as many of the individual components as they can. 0 out of 5. Here, we review the model’s best, most reliable years since its 2002 U. I'll assume that your car has run-flats. 1 to 47. My mom just bought a used 2013 Mini Cooper with 73K miles on it. I will not purchase another MINI until reliability improves. Aug 26, 2005 · Half the car is assembled by hand, so you will always see the occasional rare error, and keep in mind that person is probably 100x more likely to voice their problems here in a forum. Of course, it all comes down to the maintenance history. I could care less about the quality or reliability. [deleted] •. Turbo is good, but it’s going to be way more expensive than the Clubman you are looking at. The issue I have is that I don't know how many problems I should expect in the future. It is my understanding that the latest gen of MINIs from 2014+ for Coopers & 2017+ for Countryman are extremely reliable, from what I’ve gathered by the community. 2002 Mini Cooper S 95k Miles This car runs, but is best suited for someone looking for a project vehicle for something like Autocross that doesn't mind working on a vehicle, and body work. It is built in Melfi, Italy alongside the related Fiat 500X, with which it shares its platform. From what I can tell, she just kinda . vu nf la bl xi tx wy kq pm kg